SGU Episode 50: Difference between revisions
m (adding most current skeleton to help maintain current formatting) |
m (the skeptical puzzle section needs fixing, maybe with a hidden answer like WTN) |
||
| Line 45: | Line 45: | ||
|evan =y | |evan =y | ||
|perry =y | |perry =y | ||
|guest1 = | |guest1 =GP: {{w|Gerald Posner}}, American investigative journalist | ||
|guest2 = <!-- leave blank if no second guest --> | |guest2 = <!-- leave blank if no second guest --> | ||
|guest3 = <!-- leave blank if no third guest --> | |guest3 = <!-- leave blank if no third guest --> | ||
| Line 121: | Line 121: | ||
=== Secondhand smoke warning <small>(1:50)</small> === | === Secondhand smoke warning <small>(1:50)</small> === | ||
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20071226110708/http://www.surgeongeneral.gov/library/secondhandsmoke/report/ | *[https://web.archive.org/web/20071226110708/http://www.surgeongeneral.gov/library/secondhandsmoke/report/ Surgeon General, Richard Carmona, warns against secondhand smoke]<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20071226110708/http://www.surgeongeneral.gov/library/secondhandsmoke/report/ Office of the Surgeon General: The Health Consequences of Involuntary Exposure to Tobacco Smoke: A Report of the Surgeon General]</ref> | ||
* Another article on secondhand smoke: [http://www.webmd.com/content/article/64/72529.htm Secondhand Smoke Study Raises Ire]<ref>[http://www.webmd.com/content/article/64/72529.htm WebMD: Secondhand Smoke Study Raises Ire]</ref> | |||
== Questions/Emails/Corrections/Follow-ups | == Questions/Emails/Corrections/Follow-ups == | ||
=== Email #1: Binaural beats <small>()</small> === | === Email #1: Binaural beats <small>(11:08)</small> === | ||
<blockquote><p style="line-height:115%">Dear Skeptics, | <blockquote><p style="line-height:115%">Dear Skeptics, I am working my way through your podcasts; if you have covered this, I apologize. Clearly I have forgotten my critical thinking courses I took in college. There is a subject called "Binaural beats." Though it sounds wonderful, that is just it: it sounds wonderful. Rather than try to describe and misrepresent it, I will defer to the plethora of info out there. If you Google it, there are a couple of other names for it too. Here are a couple of links: | ||
http://web-us.com/thescience.htm | |||
http://www.pzizz.com | |||
http://www.centerpointe.com/ | |||
– Christopher Lund, United Social Agnostics<br/></p></blockquote> | |||
=== Email #2: Aubrey de Grey <small>()</small> === | === Email #2: Aubrey de Grey <small>(16:21)</small> === | ||
<blockquote><p style="line-height:115%">I have a suggestion for a topic. There is scientist by the name of Aubrey de Grey. His shtick is proclaiming that through the application of science we can extend human life by several thousand years. His ideas are an amalgam of nano-technology, molecular biology, | <blockquote><p style="line-height:115%">I have a suggestion for a topic. There is scientist by the name of Aubrey de Grey. His shtick is proclaiming that through the application of science we can extend human life by several thousand years. His ideas are an amalgam of nano-technology, molecular biology, biomechanics, etc. He seems like such a nut that it amazes me that anyone takes him seriously. And yet, he seems to be routinely written up in popular magazines such as Technology Review (MIT) and Fortune. I do not know whether you would call what he preaches pseudo-science; he is different from your run of the mill crackpot. But his ideas are so out there that he seems nuts. And yet, as I mentioned, he gets a lot of popular press. Anyway, I enjoy your podcast, and I think the ideas discussed are quite valuable.<br><br>– Regards,<br/>Mike Fattori<br><br> | ||
Review articles: http://www.technologyreview.com/sens/</p></blockquote> | |||
{{anchor|interview}} <!-- leave this anchor directly above the corresponding section that follows --> | {{anchor|interview}} <!-- leave this anchor directly above the corresponding section that follows --> | ||
== Interview with Gerald Posner <small>()</small> == | == Interview with Gerald Posner <small>(24:34)</small> == | ||
{{Page categories | {{Page categories | ||
|Interview = y <!-- | |Interview = y <!-- | ||
| Line 148: | Line 153: | ||
We suggest typing "redirect(s) created for" in front of the text you hide in the markup. --> | We suggest typing "redirect(s) created for" in front of the text you hide in the markup. --> | ||
}} | }} | ||
* Investigative journalist and author, Gerald Posner, has written some of the definitive histories of recent epic events in American history. Posner was educated at the University of California at Berkeley (1975) and Hastings Law School (1978). | * Investigative journalist and author, Gerald Posner, has written some of the definitive histories of recent epic events in American history. Posner was educated at the University of California at Berkeley (1975) and Hastings Law School (1978). | ||
== Science or Fiction <small>()</small> == | His books include: | ||
[https://www.publishersweekly.com/978-0-679-41825-2 ''Case Closed: Lee Harvey Oswald and the Assassination of JFK'' (1993)] | |||
[http://www.cnn.com/books/beginnings/9804/killing.the.dream/ ''Killing the Dream: James Earl Ray and the Assassination of Martin Luther King Jr.'' (1998)] | |||
[https://web.archive.org/web/20070807233549/www.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2003/9/4/03534.shtml ''Why America Slept: the Failure to Prevent 9/11'' (2003)]<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20070807233549/www.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2003/9/4/03534.shtml Newsmax: Clinton’s Negligence Led to 9/11]</ref><ref>[http://hnn.us/articles/1680.html History News Network: Interview with Gerald Posner: Why America Slept hnn.us/articles/1680.html]</ref> | |||
[https://www.posner.com/secrets-of-the-kingdom ''Secrets of the Kingdom: The Inside Story of the Saudi-U.S. Connection'' (2005)] | |||
== Science or Fiction <small>(1:09:30)</small> == | |||
{{SOFResults | {{SOFResults | ||
|fiction = | |fiction = aluminum foil hat | ||
|fiction2 = <!-- leave blank if absent; rarely does a host need to amend a "science" item --> | |fiction2 = <!-- leave blank if absent; rarely does a host need to amend a "science" item --> | ||
|science1 = | |science1 = brain repair | ||
|science2 = | |science2 = gum disease & atheromas | ||
|science3 = <!-- leave blank if absent --> | |science3 = <!-- leave blank if absent --> | ||
|rogue1 = | |rogue1 =evan | ||
|answer1 = | |answer1 =aluminum foil hat | ||
|rogue2 = | |rogue2 =jay | ||
|answer2 = | |answer2 =brain repair | ||
|rogue3 = | |rogue3 =perry | ||
|answer3 = | |answer3 =aluminum foil hat | ||
|rogue4 = | |rogue4 =bob | ||
|answer4 = | |answer4 =aluminum foil hat | ||
|rogue5 = <!-- leave blank if absent --> | |rogue5 = <!-- leave blank if absent --> | ||
|answer5 = <!-- leave blank if absent --> | |answer5 = <!-- leave blank if absent --> | ||
|host = | |host =steve | ||
<!-- for the result options below, | <!-- for the result options below, | ||
only put a 'y' next to one. --> | only put a 'y' next to one. --> | ||
|sweep = <!-- all the Rogues guessed wrong --> | |sweep = <!-- all the Rogues guessed wrong --> | ||
|clever = <!-- each item was guessed (Steve's preferred result) --> | |clever = <!-- each item was guessed (Steve's preferred result) --> | ||
|win = <!-- at least one Rogue guessed wrong, but not them all --> | |win =y <!-- at least one Rogue guessed wrong, but not them all --> | ||
|swept = <!-- all the Rogues guessed right --> | |swept = <!-- all the Rogues guessed right --> | ||
}} | }} | ||
| Line 185: | Line 200: | ||
''Voice-over: It's time for Science or Fiction.'' | ''Voice-over: It's time for Science or Fiction.'' | ||
{{Page categories | {{Page categories | ||
|SoF with a Theme = <!-- | |SoF with a Theme = y <!-- | ||
search for " | search for "Neurobiology (50)" to create a redirect page, then edit that page with: | ||
#REDIRECT | #REDIRECT | ||
[[ | [[SGU_Episode_50#theme]] -- you can instead use #insert_specific_SOF_section_address_here if you want to redirect to the section header instead of the theme anchor | ||
[[Category:SoF with a Theme]] | [[Category:SoF with a Theme]] | ||
| Line 198: | Line 213: | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{SOFinfo | {{SOFinfo | ||
|theme = | |theme = Neurobiology | ||
|item1 = New study shows that wearing a hat or helmet lined with aluminum foil reduces the frequency of seizures in certain epileptics. | |item1 = New study shows that wearing a hat or helmet lined with aluminum foil reduces the frequency of seizures in certain epileptics. | ||
|link1 = <ref>[url_from_SoF_show_notes PUBLICATION: TITLE]</ref> | |link1 = <ref>[url_from_SoF_show_notes PUBLICATION: TITLE]</ref> | ||
|item2 = New study shows a link between gum disease and carotid atheromas (a significant risk for stroke). | |item2 = New study shows a link between gum disease and carotid atheromas (a significant risk for stroke). | ||
|link2 = <ref>[url_from_SoF_show_notes PUBLICATION: TITLE]</ref> | |link2 = <ref>[url_from_SoF_show_notes PUBLICATION: TITLE]</ref> | ||
|item3 = Man recovers from 19 year coma with evidence of brain repair and regrowth. | |item3 = Man recovers from 19 year coma with evidence of brain repair and regrowth. | ||
|link3 = <ref>[url_from_SoF_show_notes PUBLICATION: TITLE]</ref> | |link3 = <ref>[url_from_SoF_show_notes PUBLICATION: TITLE]</ref> | ||
|}} | |}} | ||
=== Evan's Response === | |||
=== | === Jay's Response === | ||
=== | === Perry's Response === | ||
=== | === Bob's Response === | ||
=== | === Steve Explains Item #3 === | ||
=== | === Steve Explains Item #2 === | ||
=== | === Steve Explains Item #1 === | ||
== Skeptical Puzzle <small>()</small> == | == Skeptical Puzzle <small>(1:18:28)</small> == | ||
<blockquote>Last Week's puzzle: | <blockquote>Last Week's puzzle: | ||
In the old game show, Let's Make A Deal, contestants were asked to pick which of three doors they thought contained a valuable prize. Once the contestant picked a door, the host, Monty Hall, would often open one of the two doors not chosen and then ask the contestant if they would like to change their pick to the other door left unopened. The question is, should a contestant stick with their original choice, change to the other door, or there is no difference statistically? | |||
Answer: The contestant should change her pick to the other door. If she sticks with her first pick her chances of winning is 1/3, if she changes her pick her chances of winning is 2/3.</blockquote> | |||
< | === New Puzzle <small>(1:21:57)</small> === | ||
<blockquote> | <blockquote>Name the medical pseudoscience that, although now is thoroughly disproved and rejected by mainstream science, at its inception was on the correct side of a major scientific debate of the time.</blockquote> | ||
== Signoff/Announcements <small>()</small> == | == Signoff/Announcements <small>(1:22:51)</small> == | ||
<!-- ** if the signoff/announcements don't immediately follow the QoW or if the QoW comments take a few minutes, it would be appropriate to include a timestamp for when this part starts --> | <!-- ** if the signoff/announcements don't immediately follow the QoW or if the QoW comments take a few minutes, it would be appropriate to include a timestamp for when this part starts --> | ||
Revision as of 20:22, 15 February 2022
|
This transcript is not finished. Please help us finish it! Add a Transcribing template to the top of this transcript before you start so that we don't duplicate your efforts. |
Template:Editing required (w/links)
This is an outline for a typical episode's transcription. Not all of these segments feature in each episode.
There may also be additional/special segments not listed in this outline.
You can use this outline to help structure the transcription. Click "Edit" above to begin.
| SGU Episode 50 |
|---|
| July 5th 2006 |
 |
| (brief caption for the episode icon) |
| Skeptical Rogues |
| S: Steven Novella |
B: Bob Novella |
J: Jay Novella |
E: Evan Bernstein |
P: Perry DeAngelis |
| Guest |
GP: Gerald Posner, American investigative journalist |
| Quote of the Week |
Quote |
Author |
| Links |
| Download Podcast |
| Show Notes |
| Forum Discussion |
Introduction
You're listening to the Skeptics' Guide to the Universe, your escape to reality.
S: Hello and welcome to the Skeptics' Guide to the Universe. Today is Wednesday, July 5th 2006. This is your host, Steven Novella, president of the New England Skeptical Society. Joining me this evening are...Bob Novella.
B: Good evening everyone.
S: ... Even Bernstein ...
E: Hello to my friends on planet Earth.
S: ... Perry DeAngelis ...
P: Good evening.
S: ... and Jay Novella ...
J: Hey guys, good to be here.
S: We have an all-testosterone show this week, which is the first time in quite a wile actually.
J: All-male-review.
S: Since Rebecca joined the crew. Rebecca is in Europe this week... and we couldn't get her onto the show from Europe, although she's actually going to be in Europe next week but promised she will try to get on the show next week so we will see. She says she can get access to the internet in England but not where she is now, where I think is in France.
P: We technically can barely get her on from Boston.
S: (laughs) That's true.
P: Be interesting to see if we can get her from Europe.
S: So it shouldn't really matter.
B: So this is our fiftieth podcast.
S: Yes. It is a bit of a milestone, this is number fifty, big five-oh. It seems like only a year ago we started doing this.
E: (laughs) At least, and thank you all of the listeners who have helped make this podcast very successful today.
J: Aboslutely.
News Items
S:
B:
C:
J:
E:
(laughs) (laughter) (applause) [inaudible]
Secondhand smoke warning (1:50)
- Surgeon General, Richard Carmona, warns against secondhand smoke[1]
- Another article on secondhand smoke: Secondhand Smoke Study Raises Ire[2]
Questions/Emails/Corrections/Follow-ups
Email #1: Binaural beats (11:08)
Dear Skeptics, I am working my way through your podcasts; if you have covered this, I apologize. Clearly I have forgotten my critical thinking courses I took in college. There is a subject called "Binaural beats." Though it sounds wonderful, that is just it: it sounds wonderful. Rather than try to describe and misrepresent it, I will defer to the plethora of info out there. If you Google it, there are a couple of other names for it too. Here are a couple of links:
http://web-us.com/thescience.htm http://www.pzizz.com http://www.centerpointe.com/
– Christopher Lund, United Social Agnostics
Email #2: Aubrey de Grey (16:21)
I have a suggestion for a topic. There is scientist by the name of Aubrey de Grey. His shtick is proclaiming that through the application of science we can extend human life by several thousand years. His ideas are an amalgam of nano-technology, molecular biology, biomechanics, etc. He seems like such a nut that it amazes me that anyone takes him seriously. And yet, he seems to be routinely written up in popular magazines such as Technology Review (MIT) and Fortune. I do not know whether you would call what he preaches pseudo-science; he is different from your run of the mill crackpot. But his ideas are so out there that he seems nuts. And yet, as I mentioned, he gets a lot of popular press. Anyway, I enjoy your podcast, and I think the ideas discussed are quite valuable.
– Regards,
Mike Fattori
Review articles: http://www.technologyreview.com/sens/
Interview with Gerald Posner (24:34)
- Investigative journalist and author, Gerald Posner, has written some of the definitive histories of recent epic events in American history. Posner was educated at the University of California at Berkeley (1975) and Hastings Law School (1978).
His books include:
Case Closed: Lee Harvey Oswald and the Assassination of JFK (1993)
Killing the Dream: James Earl Ray and the Assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. (1998)
Why America Slept: the Failure to Prevent 9/11 (2003)[3][4]
Secrets of the Kingdom: The Inside Story of the Saudi-U.S. Connection (2005)
Science or Fiction (1:09:30)
| Answer | Item |
|---|---|
| Fiction | Aluminum foil hat |
| Science | Brain repair |
| Science | Gum disease & atheromas |
| Host | Result |
|---|---|
| Steve | win |
| Rogue | Guess |
|---|---|
Evan | Aluminum foil hat |
Jay | Brain repair |
Perry | Aluminum foil hat |
Bob | Aluminum foil hat |
Voice-over: It's time for Science or Fiction.
Theme: Neurobiology Item #1: New study shows that wearing a hat or helmet lined with aluminum foil reduces the frequency of seizures in certain epileptics.[5]
Item #2: New study shows a link between gum disease and carotid atheromas (a significant risk for stroke).[6]
Item #3: Man recovers from 19 year coma with evidence of brain repair and regrowth.[7]
Evan's Response
Jay's Response
Perry's Response
Bob's Response
Steve Explains Item #3
Steve Explains Item #2
Steve Explains Item #1
Skeptical Puzzle (1:18:28)
Last Week's puzzle:
In the old game show, Let's Make A Deal, contestants were asked to pick which of three doors they thought contained a valuable prize. Once the contestant picked a door, the host, Monty Hall, would often open one of the two doors not chosen and then ask the contestant if they would like to change their pick to the other door left unopened. The question is, should a contestant stick with their original choice, change to the other door, or there is no difference statistically?
Answer: The contestant should change her pick to the other door. If she sticks with her first pick her chances of winning is 1/3, if she changes her pick her chances of winning is 2/3.
New Puzzle (1:21:57)
Name the medical pseudoscience that, although now is thoroughly disproved and rejected by mainstream science, at its inception was on the correct side of a major scientific debate of the time.
Signoff/Announcements (1:22:51)
S: —and until next week, this is your Skeptics' Guide to the Universe.
S: The Skeptics' Guide to the Universe is produced by the New England Skeptical Society. For information on this and other podcasts, please visit our website at www.theskepticsguide.org. Please send us your questions, suggestions, and other feedback; you can use the "Contact Us" page on our website, or you can send us an email to info@theskepticsguide.org. 'Theorem' is produced by Kineto and is used with permission.
Today I Learned
- Fact/Description, possibly with an article reference[8]
- Fact/Description
- Fact/Description
Notes
References
- ↑ Office of the Surgeon General: The Health Consequences of Involuntary Exposure to Tobacco Smoke: A Report of the Surgeon General
- ↑ WebMD: Secondhand Smoke Study Raises Ire
- ↑ Newsmax: Clinton’s Negligence Led to 9/11
- ↑ History News Network: Interview with Gerald Posner: Why America Slept hnn.us/articles/1680.html
- ↑ [url_from_SoF_show_notes PUBLICATION: TITLE]
- ↑ [url_from_SoF_show_notes PUBLICATION: TITLE]
- ↑ [url_from_SoF_show_notes PUBLICATION: TITLE]
- ↑ [url_for_TIL publication: title]
Vocabulary
|
|
|